Broker, Marketplace or Direct: How to Sell a Small Business
Should you sell through a broker or M&A advisor, a marketplace like Acquire.com, or straight to a buyer? Fees, timelines and when each one makes sense, with sourced numbers.
Short answer: use a marketplace like Acquire.com if your business is under about $1M in price, is software, and you can run the process yourself. Use a broker or M&A advisor if you are above a few million, want competing offers, or don't have the time. Go direct to one buyer only when you already know who should own the company and have a fair-value number in hand.
What each route costs and how long it takes
| Route | Typical fee | Typical time | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marketplace (Acquire.com) | 6–8% closing fee, plus $25–$100 a month to list | 81 days on average for 185 Acquire deals in 2025 | Small SaaS and online businesses, founder-run process |
| Marketplace (Empire Flippers) | Tiered commission, about $129K on a $1M sale | About 130 days average | Content, ecommerce and online businesses |
| Broker or M&A advisor | Success fee of about 3–5% at mid sizes (4.8% typical at a $5M sale); many also charge $5K–$10K a month | 6–7 months advisor-led, often longer | $2M+ businesses, competitive process |
| Direct to a buyer | Lawyer and accountant fees only | Varies; fastest when the buyer is ready | You already know the right buyer |
Fees on marketplaces fall as price rises: Acquire.com charges 8% below $250K, 7% from $250K to $1M and 6% above $1M. Advisors work the other way round: the percentage falls as the deal grows, but monthly retainers make small deals expensive.
When a marketplace makes sense
Marketplaces put your listing in front of many buyers quickly. Acquire.com says it has more than 500,000 registered buyers. They work best when your numbers are clean, your price is fair and the business is easy to understand. Acquire's own data, as reported by Founderpath, shows listings priced at fair value drew serious interest from about 60% of active buyers, and far fewer when priced above market.
The catch: you run the process. You answer buyers, sort serious from curious, negotiate the letter of intent and manage diligence.
When a broker or advisor makes sense
An advisor earns the fee by building competition. The IBBA's Q2 2026 Market Pulse found 87% of deals over $5M drew at least three offers. Multiple offers move price and terms, including how much is paid in cash at closing.
Ask any advisor: how many deals like mine have you closed in the last two years, who are the likely buyers, and is the monthly fee taken off the success fee? Firmex's 2025 survey of advisors found 57% of firms credit it.
When going direct makes sense
Going direct saves the fee and keeps the sale quiet. It works when you already know a buyer you trust and you have an outside sense of value. The risk is one-buyer negotiation: without a second offer, you have no proof the price is fair. Get a valuation first. See How much is my business worth?
Questions founders ask
Is a broker worth the fee under $1M? Often not for software, where marketplaces reach many buyers for a lower percentage. For service businesses with local buyers, a good broker can still pay for itself.
Can I list on a marketplace and use an advisor? Some advisors list on marketplaces as one channel. Check that you won't pay two success fees.
Does the route change who buys? Yes. Marketplaces lean toward individuals and small funds; advisors reach PE and strategic buyers. See Who buys businesses like mine?
Vangal's view
The route matters less than the price you start from and the buyers you let in. A fair price on a marketplace usually beats an inflated price with an expensive advisor. If you already know you want a long-term owner who keeps your team, it is worth talking directly to a few buyers like that before you list.
Sources
- Acquire.com, How much does it cost to sell? and seller pricing.
- Founderpath, SaaS acquisitions: lessons from $500M in closed deals, citing Acquire.com's 2025 data (81 days, fair-value interest) and Empire Flippers' average sale time.
- Livmo, Selling SaaS: marketplace vs advisor, citing Acquire.com's 2025 report (185 deals) and Firmex's 2025 advisor fee survey of 456 advisors. Livmo is an M&A advisor.
- IBBA and M&A Source, Market Pulse Q2 2026, as reported by Webull.
More in Selling to Micro Private Equity, or see what small SaaS companies sell for in Small SaaS Valuation Multiples (2026).
Thinking about selling?
Vangal buys and holds founder-built software and services businesses. Start a confidential conversation.
Email hello@vangal.com